S1AL has created a new argument category.
There’s the “No True Scotsman” argument we all know about. His corollary is the “UMC Amish as TradCon”. There are very small, very cloistered groups like that, but good luck finding them. There are good churches out there, but there aren’t a lot of them. You aren’t going to get many takers to talking about the “Church” when you’re speaking from an ultra-thin minority.
UMC = upper middle class.
This is definitely a corollary to the “No True Scotsman” fallacy. I’m not even sure that “UMC Amish” churches exist, but even if they do they are so small and so few as to be almost impossible to find. Even if you found one, they probably wouldn’t let you in since you weren’t born into their church.